Chinese Muslim Mosque Issue Shows That Race, Not Religion Is The Biggest Problem In Malaysia.
Getting official permission to build churches it seems sometimes takes decades, with all sorts of obstacles to surmount and silly objections being given by the authorities. Hindu temples meanwhile get demolished at the drop of a five sen coin, when underworked local councils are bored and have nothing better to do. The same applies, albeit at a lesser frequency to Buddhist temples too.
Mosques on the other hand get super easy passage and are constructed regularly with government blessing and the taxpayers' money. The reason is two-fold. One is to pander to the Muslim voter and ensure his loyalty to the ruling party. The other is to maintain the facade that we are actually an 'Islamic' nation.
But here is a report about how difficult it really is to get approval to build a mosque! On the face of it this seems unlikely and is probably a vicious rumour. But wait. The reluctance to give permission to build these mosques has another equation to it. They are mosques meant for Chinese Muslims. So it is AOK for these chaps to convert and become saudara baru, but to have masjids of their own? No way brudder! You may be of the same religion, but brudder you are of a different race. And THAT my friends is what matters most in this fair land of ours. The land which has given a fresh and new perspective to institutionalized apartheid.
The report in today's NST follows:
The Malaysian Chinese Muslim Association (MCMA) is facing difficulties in getting approval from state governments to build mosques for their community.
MCMA vice-president Mohd Ridhuan Tee Abdullah said it was unfair for Perak mufti Datuk Seri Harussani Idris to say that state religious departments did not prevent the Chinese community from applying to build their own mosques.
He said MCMA had been trying to build a Chinese mosque in Selangor for about a decade but claimed that the religious authorities were not even interested in hearing their proposal.
"In our last meeting with the former director of the Selangor religious department a couple of years ago, he told us there was no way he would approve a Chinese mosque.
"For him, Islam in Malaysia is all about the Malays and the Malay language," he said when commenting on Harussani’s remarks.
Harussani had lambasted his Perlis counterpart Dr Mohd Asri Zainul Abidin for implying that state governments denied the rights of Chinese Muslims to have their mosques.
Mohd Ridhuan defended the Perlis mufti, saying that the MCMA’s experience in Selangor and Malacca showed that some religious authorities failed to understand the universality of Islam. The Malacca Chinese Muslim Association had its application to build a Chinese mosque rejected three years ago. Mohd Ridhuan claimed that MCMA also proposed the building of a mosque and Islamic centre for the Chinese community to Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Datuk Dr Abdullah Md Zin but there was no further response.
He, however, was happy with the Selangor mufti Datuk Mohd Tamyis Abdul Majid’s assurance that the state would seriously look into applications to build a Chinese mosque in Selangor. "MCMA will definitely bring up the proposal again and we hope the Selangor state government would approve our application," Mohd Ridhuan said.
MCMA is hoping that a Chinese mosque would reflect Chinese design and architecture and also encourage non-Muslim Chinese to visit.
While Harussani claimed that state religious authorities did not prevent the Chinese from building mosques, he did not explain why there had yet to exist such a mosque in Malaysia.
Dr Mohd Asri when contacted said he hoped his Perak counterpart would be less emotional when dealing with such an issue. "No one is belittling the religious authorities. As a mufti, I believe in showing Islam in its true form, as a caring, peaceful and understanding religion," he said.
***** Moral of the story in the Malaysian context: Convert to Islam if you must but don't expect any less discrimination. A non-Malay you are and a non-Malay you always will be.
Image - Source
Mosques on the other hand get super easy passage and are constructed regularly with government blessing and the taxpayers' money. The reason is two-fold. One is to pander to the Muslim voter and ensure his loyalty to the ruling party. The other is to maintain the facade that we are actually an 'Islamic' nation.
But here is a report about how difficult it really is to get approval to build a mosque! On the face of it this seems unlikely and is probably a vicious rumour. But wait. The reluctance to give permission to build these mosques has another equation to it. They are mosques meant for Chinese Muslims. So it is AOK for these chaps to convert and become saudara baru, but to have masjids of their own? No way brudder! You may be of the same religion, but brudder you are of a different race. And THAT my friends is what matters most in this fair land of ours. The land which has given a fresh and new perspective to institutionalized apartheid.
The report in today's NST follows:
The Malaysian Chinese Muslim Association (MCMA) is facing difficulties in getting approval from state governments to build mosques for their community.
MCMA vice-president Mohd Ridhuan Tee Abdullah said it was unfair for Perak mufti Datuk Seri Harussani Idris to say that state religious departments did not prevent the Chinese community from applying to build their own mosques.
He said MCMA had been trying to build a Chinese mosque in Selangor for about a decade but claimed that the religious authorities were not even interested in hearing their proposal.
"In our last meeting with the former director of the Selangor religious department a couple of years ago, he told us there was no way he would approve a Chinese mosque.
"For him, Islam in Malaysia is all about the Malays and the Malay language," he said when commenting on Harussani’s remarks.
Harussani had lambasted his Perlis counterpart Dr Mohd Asri Zainul Abidin for implying that state governments denied the rights of Chinese Muslims to have their mosques.
Mohd Ridhuan defended the Perlis mufti, saying that the MCMA’s experience in Selangor and Malacca showed that some religious authorities failed to understand the universality of Islam. The Malacca Chinese Muslim Association had its application to build a Chinese mosque rejected three years ago. Mohd Ridhuan claimed that MCMA also proposed the building of a mosque and Islamic centre for the Chinese community to Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Datuk Dr Abdullah Md Zin but there was no further response.
He, however, was happy with the Selangor mufti Datuk Mohd Tamyis Abdul Majid’s assurance that the state would seriously look into applications to build a Chinese mosque in Selangor. "MCMA will definitely bring up the proposal again and we hope the Selangor state government would approve our application," Mohd Ridhuan said.
MCMA is hoping that a Chinese mosque would reflect Chinese design and architecture and also encourage non-Muslim Chinese to visit.
While Harussani claimed that state religious authorities did not prevent the Chinese from building mosques, he did not explain why there had yet to exist such a mosque in Malaysia.
Dr Mohd Asri when contacted said he hoped his Perak counterpart would be less emotional when dealing with such an issue. "No one is belittling the religious authorities. As a mufti, I believe in showing Islam in its true form, as a caring, peaceful and understanding religion," he said.
***** Moral of the story in the Malaysian context: Convert to Islam if you must but don't expect any less discrimination. A non-Malay you are and a non-Malay you always will be.
Image - Source
Labels: Racial Intolerance, Religion.
6 Comments:
This Perlis Mufti fella should win the nobel peace price hands down including the Jenzhiz Khan award for true guts !
By Golly finally sonebody I can respect
IMHO, it is part of Mahathir work in progress "Malay dilemma" cultural revolution plan.
In fact, it do more harm to the race itself than other race.
Tun Mahathir's Grand vision(?) is to assimilate the Chinese Malaysian into the Malay race, but he failed. That's why, some times ago, he did said that the Chinese are the most difficult race to be assimilated!
So, forget about the Chinese mosque. If you masuk Islam, just wear baju Melayu, Songkok, pray in the present Malay/Arabic mosque.
Don't forget, those Indian muslim who haven't been assimilated into the Malay race would still remain as Indian Muslim/mamak with their name a/l & a/p. Don't even dream of merging their Party into UMNO or given a bumi status. Am I right?
How do you expect assimilation when Bolehland is based on race-based politics?
Barisan Najis is worthless/irrelevent in a colourless/bumiputera-less Bolehland.
You said, "A non-Malay you are and a non-Malay you always will be." That's not true. Look at the number of ethnic Indians who are Muslims and who are accepted not only as Malays but bumis to boot.
Some of them hold high office and also are considered as so-called "Umnoputras". The second Finance Minister Nor Yaakop aka Top Cat is one. Another is Information Minister Zam. You just have to take a look at the photographs of our goverment cabinet ministers; it's not difficult to tell who are ethnic Malays and who are of Indian descent. Samy Velu is Indian but he is not Muslim, otherwise he would not be able to make it to top dog status in the MIC. I wonder if there are any Indian Muslim mosques in Malaysia.
You have a point there Outsider. I don't claim to be very knowledgeable in ethnology but I believe that many of these 'Indian Muslims' do come under the umbrella of 'rumpun Melayu' and they satisfy the constitutional requirements of 'being a Malay.' That however does not apply to the new converts orsaudara baru of any race including Indians.
Post a Comment
<< Home